Another View -- Stephen Parente: When Obamacare takes full effect, NH will be hit hard
NEW HAMPSHIRE, buckle up. Over the next few months, you’ll learn how much your health insurance premiums will go up for next year. The early evidence isn’t good — the percentage increase could be in the double digits.
But that’s nothing compared to what you’ll face in 2017. In May, I released a comprehensive study showing how the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) will likely play out in New Hampshire over the next few years. The diagnosis isn’t good.
First, the short version. In two years, the ACA’s structural problems will lead to substantial premium increases. Once that happens, people will likely leave the insurance market in droves. They’ll have little choice —they won’t be able to afford health insurance because federal subsidies won’t keep up with the rapid price increases. Within a decade, this could swell the ranks of the state’s uninsured by 133 percent percent.
This isn’t baseless speculation. I reached this conclusion by using a peer-reviewed economic model published in several health journals. It was funded by both private and government sources, including the Department of Health and Human Services, and has been cited by multiple Supreme Court justices in ACA-related rulings.
But why won’t this happen until 2017? Because that’s the year when the Affordable Care Act goes into full effect and certain temporary provisions begin to sunset. The changes will affect all plans sold for 2017 and beyond.
Two big changes will occur that year: Insurance companies will no longer have access to ACA’s “re-insurance” and “risk corridor” programs. The first item currently allows insurers to bill the government for the most expensive patients; the second one guarantees that the industry’s losses will be subsidized by you. When these two programs end, the insurance industry won’t have access to taxpayer money.
That leaves New Hampshire’s citizens to pick up the tab. Without taxpayer money, insurers in the state will increase plan premiums to cover the sudden shortfall. They’ll have no other choice — the other option is to go out of business.
You might not have a choice, either. The data predict that the average 2017 premiums for the cheapest individuals plan in New Hampshire may jump from $1,424 to $6,741 — a 373 percent increase. Undoubtedly, this will be far too expensive for many people. No insurance may be the only financially sound option.
This will cause a chain reaction in the insurance market. As people leave the exchanges, insurers will have fewer customers who can shoulder health care costs. Thus, for 2018, they’ll have to raise prices again —which will only cause more people to leave. This cycle could repeat itself indefinitely.
Employer health care coverage won’t stem the losses. After 2016, many businesses will stop offering health insurance because it’s also getting too expensive for them. I estimate that nearly 90,000 people could lose employer coverage in New Hampshire over the next decade.
This rapid turn of events leaves more people who need health insurance from the exchanges. Those same exchanges, meanwhile, are hemorrhaging customers because they’re becoming more expensive every year. Stuck in this cycle, many will find the IRS “shared responsibility fee”—the tax for not having health insurance—a far cheaper option. My analysis indicates that this could increase the number of uninsured by 133 percent to more than 130,000 people within a decade.
Think of what this means for the Affordable Care Act. Its architects promised that it would make health care cheaper while providing universal health care. Instead, it will make health care unaffordable for many while leaving more New Hampshire residents uninsured. This health care cure may be worse than the disease.
Dr. Stephen Parente is a professor of health finance, the associate dean of the Carlson School of Management, and the director of the Medical Industry Leadership Institute at the University of Minnesota.