Dec 4, 2014
Oct 30, 2014
Oct 2, 2014
Sep 25, 2014
Supreme Court upholds conviction in Hooksett man's killing of wife
CONCORD — The state Supreme Court upheld the second-degree murder conviction of a Hooksett man in the stabbing death of his wife five years ago at a New Boston campground saying the trial judge did not err in her instructions to the jury.
Robert Dupont, 65, was convicted of two counts of second-degree murder in the Oct. 12, 2008, murder of Jo-Ann Francis, 60. In appealing the convictions, he argued that Judge Gillian Abramson, who presided at the Hillsborough County Superior Court trial, did not explain to jurors that the state had to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he had not acted in self-defense.
The stabbing happened in a camper the couple had at Friendly Beaver Campground. The two, who were drinking that day, got into an argument. Francis swore and screamed at her husband and said she was calling police. He left the trailer when she made the threat, but then changed his mind and went back inside.
Dupont maintained Francis had a knife in her hand when he went back inside. The two again exchanged words and as he turned to leave, Francis grabbed him and cut his left arm.
The two struggled and he tried to take the knife from her and that's when she suffered nine stab wounds to her head, face, neck, arm and hands. The stab wound to her neck proved fatal.
Dupont said he didn't know how Francis suffered the stab wounds; he surmised it happened during the struggle for the knife, according to the Supreme Court ruling.
He was charged with second-degree murder, but at trial jurors were given the option of considering lesser included charges of provocation manslaughter, reckless manslaughter or negligent homicide.
Abramson explained the elements in each of the charges that the state had to prove and, at the end after a bench conference, said if jurors had a reasonable doubt as to whether Dupont acted in self-defense, they must find him not guilty on all charges.
Dupont argued the judge should have included the self-defense instruction each time she explained a charge and not just once at the end of her instructions.
The court ruled that although the instructions for each charged offense did not separately include self-defense, the instructions as a whole properly informed the jury of the state's burden.
"Viewing the instructions as a whole, and not in isolation, we do not find any realistic possibility that the jury was misled as to its obligation to consider the issue of self-defense," the court said. It noted the judge instructed jurors if they "have a reasonable doubt as to whether the defendant acted in self-defense, you must find him not guilty on all charges and your deliberations must end at that point."
It was an instruction that came just before the jury headed into deliberations.
"Based upon the instruction as a whole, then, no reasonable juror would have believed that he or she could return a verdict of guilty as to any charge without first considering whether the state had negated self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt," the court said in upholding Dupont's conviction.
READER COMMENTS: 0
- Guilty plea brings closure for family of store clerk who suffered heart attack after theft - 0
- Police pursuit begins in Plaistow, ends at Kingston police station - 0
- Judge orders Londonderry man to begin serving jail sentence for growing pot - 0
- Woman accused of fleeing with daughter to be arraigned Thursday - 0
- Woman found in Mass. home with dead babies charged with murder - 0
- Manchester Crimewatch: Man wants bail conditions modified so he can go home - 0
- Exeter woman faces arson charge for allegedly setting her own home ablaze - 1
- Keene police arrest two alleged embezzlers - 0
- Plaistow police urge public to keep cars locked - 0
READER COMMENTS: 0
- Charles M. Arlinghaus: Read these books, OK? - 0
- Jeb takes a dip: First Flavor of the Week - 0
- Asking about marriage: The Census should keep doing it - 0
- NHIAA Div. I Boys' Basketball Preview: Memorial, Central look to be in the mix again - 0
- Innovations abound at UNH event - 0
- Rinne wins duel with Rask as Predators edge Bruins - 0
- One-alarm fire kept to chimney area of Bridgewater home - 0
- Monarchs head to Portland Wednesday - 0
- Nashua woman hurt in Pelham crash - 0
Bush 41, 43 and ... 45?
Rival NH Republican caucus seeks own voice
Another View -- Ross Gittell and Jeremy Hitchcock: By focusing on student success, NH community colleges prove their value
Another View -- David Scannell: A justified federal civil rights action in Manchester's schools
Taxi fail: City regulations don't work
All lives matter: Even Al Sharpton says so
Jeb takes a dip: First Flavor of the Week
Charles M. Arlinghaus: Read these books, OK?
Police arrest pair after bullets fly
- Whom do you think bears the brunt of the blame for the mayhem this weekend in Keene?
- KSC students
- KSC administration
- Visitors from out of town
- A combination of any/all of the above
- Total Votes: 2483