Home » Opinion » Editorials
Sodas and power: A setback for the nanny state
This is the fate Judge Milton Tingling of the New York State Supreme Court spared the Big Apple when on Tuesday he struck down Bloomberg's soda ban. Judge Tingling noted that the soda ban was not a soda ban as much as it was a seemingly random (thus "arbitrary and capricious") ban on certain sizes of certain sodas sold at certain establishments - while allowing larger, less healthy beverages to be served unmolested at competing establishments or even in the same ones.
For example, the regulation forbade the serving of a 500 ml. (16.9 ounces) soda or energy drink at a movie theater, restaurant or stadium, but allowed the same drink to be sold at any convenience store. It forbade the serving of a 20-ounce soda at a deli or diner while allowing the same restaurant to sell a milkshake with more than three times the calories of a ?16-ounce soda.
Bloomberg pushed his soda dictate through his hand-picked board of health, not through the city council. Tingling sharply discerned that the board had the legal authority to issue emergency restrictions on individual behavior to contain outbreaks of communicable diseases, but it had no authority to use those emergency powers to prohibit people from buying particular sizes of otherwise legal beverages when there was no state of emergency.
This expansion of government's legitimate emergency powers for the purpose of controlling individual behaviors is characteristic of the nanny state. Tingling was shrewd enough to see that "obesity" is a matter of personal, not "public" health, and to strike down Bloomberg's power grab. Other judges in other places will not be so wise, which is why keeping nannies like Bloomberg out of office is essential to the protection of individual liberty.
READER COMMENTS: 0
- Board of Ed finds in favor of Goffstown; Dunbarton plans Supreme Court appeal - 2
- Tech conference sparks ideas and imagination - 0
- Nashua assessment tests miss the mark - 1
- St. A's board of trustees responds to criticism of graduation change - 2
- Officials proposing cutting Derry school budget by $1.4 million - 0
- St. Anselm in a stir over graduation date change - 13
- Nashua schools struggle to find more time for middle-school math - 0
- Former Gov. Lynch chosen for PSU Robert Frost award - 0
- Keene State College gets funding to further biology research - 0
READER COMMENTS: 0
- Two Manchester women arrested in separate shoplifting incidents in Hooksett - 1
- Maine police search car belonging to husband of Londonderry shooting victim - 0
- Man arrested after chase, threatening to shoot police in Bow - 0
- Good Samaritan pins Manchester purse snatcher - 0
- Homeless man who saved woman from river: 'I don't consider myself a hero' - 9
- High School Basketball: Rivalries renewed in QCIBT - 0
- Dave D'Onofrio's Patriots Notebook: Will they get everything on their list? - 0
- Tuohy brothers add new restaurant in familiar spot - 0
- New Horizons volunteers deliver groceries and good cheer, making Christmas special - 0
Londonderry schools placed on lockdown after soldier's unplanned visit to high school causes alarm
Police say woman tried to steal 15 iPads