Home » Neighborhood News » The Salem Observer
October 04. 2012 8:12PM
Windham: Dress code has legal precedent
WINDHAM — School officials say a legal opinion reinforces the district’s authority to continue enforcing its dress code policy.
“According to legal counsel, all of the restrictions found in the Windham School District’s dress code can be found in many upheld by the courts,” School Board Chairman Bruce Anderson wrote in a letter read by board member Michelle Farrell.
The goal of the policy is to provide dress guidelines for students that are practical and create a safe and appropriate learning environment, according to the letter.
“It is well-settled law that school districts can enact restrictions that require students to wear clothes that properly cover them,” the letter said.
It went on to say that “courts will not interfere with a school district’s determination of proper width of sleeveless top straps, height of shirt backs, or proper length of shorts or skirts, rather, courts will defer to the school district’s judgment on what is appropriate.”
The question of constitutionality was brought up by former School Board member Michael Hatem in September. At the time Hatem said the policy violated the “Tinker” and “Bannister” cases in which courts ruled that student’s First Amendment rights couldn’t be infringed upon unless the school is trying to prevent an actual risk.
Hatem asked the School Board to stop enforcing the policy until it was re-evaluated and possibly simplified. The board and Superintendent Henry LaBranche continued to enforce the policy while getting a legal opinion.
LaBranche said neither case was a defense for calling the dress code unconstitutional and that more recent case law in the last two decades provided school districts with the authority to enforce reasonable dress codes.
“That’s essentially what has been confirmed by counsel,” LaBranche said.
Staff members will monitor enforcement of the dress code and review the results at the end of the year to determine whether any modifications are necessary, LaBranche said.
LaBranche said he personally has not received any further complaints about the dress code.
School Board member Stephanie Wimmer said many parents, students and staff members have expressed support for the dress code since the issue arose.
“I have not had any other parent or student come to me with any kind of concerns,” Wimmer said.
Hatem did the right thing in raising his legal concerns, Wimmer said, and she hopes that all parents feel comfortable speaking to the board about their issues.
“We take those concerns seriously,” Wimmer said.
As a result of Hatem’s actions, Wimmer said, the board did more due diligence on the policy and she’s confident they’re in a good place.
Michael Hatem could not be reached for comment.
jhanson@newstote.com
“According to legal counsel, all of the restrictions found in the Windham School District’s dress code can be found in many upheld by the courts,” School Board Chairman Bruce Anderson wrote in a letter read by board member Michelle Farrell.
The goal of the policy is to provide dress guidelines for students that are practical and create a safe and appropriate learning environment, according to the letter.
“It is well-settled law that school districts can enact restrictions that require students to wear clothes that properly cover them,” the letter said.
It went on to say that “courts will not interfere with a school district’s determination of proper width of sleeveless top straps, height of shirt backs, or proper length of shorts or skirts, rather, courts will defer to the school district’s judgment on what is appropriate.”
The question of constitutionality was brought up by former School Board member Michael Hatem in September. At the time Hatem said the policy violated the “Tinker” and “Bannister” cases in which courts ruled that student’s First Amendment rights couldn’t be infringed upon unless the school is trying to prevent an actual risk.
Hatem asked the School Board to stop enforcing the policy until it was re-evaluated and possibly simplified. The board and Superintendent Henry LaBranche continued to enforce the policy while getting a legal opinion.
LaBranche said neither case was a defense for calling the dress code unconstitutional and that more recent case law in the last two decades provided school districts with the authority to enforce reasonable dress codes.
“That’s essentially what has been confirmed by counsel,” LaBranche said.
Staff members will monitor enforcement of the dress code and review the results at the end of the year to determine whether any modifications are necessary, LaBranche said.
LaBranche said he personally has not received any further complaints about the dress code.
School Board member Stephanie Wimmer said many parents, students and staff members have expressed support for the dress code since the issue arose.
“I have not had any other parent or student come to me with any kind of concerns,” Wimmer said.
Hatem did the right thing in raising his legal concerns, Wimmer said, and she hopes that all parents feel comfortable speaking to the board about their issues.
“We take those concerns seriously,” Wimmer said.
As a result of Hatem’s actions, Wimmer said, the board did more due diligence on the policy and she’s confident they’re in a good place.
Michael Hatem could not be reached for comment.
jhanson@newstote.com
Salem » Local Events
- Pelham High nurse named School Nurse of the Year - 0
- MAKE SURE IT'S ME Opens at West End Studio Theatre - 0
- Harmonica Master James Cotton forced to postpone May 25 Londonderry Performance - 0
- Our Gourmet: A touch of mystery, flavors of the Orient at Soho in Hudson - 0
- Group continues effort to expand Cotton Valley Trail in Broofield - 0
- For Bedford girl, exploring the world in geography bee a ‘great thing to do’ - 0
- Loon Mountain Resort Unleashes New Obstacles for July 13 Monster Mud Run - 0
- Location Change for N.H. Fish and Game Commission Meeting June 12 - 0
- Jim Beauregard's Tasting Notes: Samuel Adams makes its can debut - 0
Reviving the Piscataqua River Wherry
READER COMMENTS: 0Press Releases
Help Combat Invasive Plants; Loaner Tools & Statewide Web Resource
READER COMMENTS: 0GREENLAND, N.H. -- Groups working to combat invasive plants on the Seacoast can now borrow some tough "Weed Wrenching" tools to make their efforts more effective.
Cranmore Opens for Spring/Summer Operations on May 25
READER COMMENTS: 0NORTH CONWAY, NH – Cranmore Mountain opens for its third summer season on Saturday, May 25, 2013. Cranmore's Mountain Adventure Park is sure to make a memorable Memorial Day weekend for...
0
29th Annual Chowder Fest Kicks-Off Summer on June 1st
0
Loon Mountain Resort Opens for Summer May 25
0
Seven Earn N.H. Fish and Game Commission Awards of Excellence


