Home » Opinion » Columns
May 22. 2012 8:22PM
Another View -- Kathy Sullivan: Vaillancourt, Mead flaps eclipse 'war' on schools
The New Hampshire House of Representatives has been awash in kerfuffles. There was the blow-up by Manchester Rep. Steve Vaillancourt when Speaker Bill O’Brien attempted to silence Vaillancourt during a debate on a voter identification bill. The Manchester legislator was arguing with O’Brien over his disparate treatment of legislators speaking in favor of the bill against those who were against. O’Brien threatened to have Vaillancourt removed, Vaillancourt responded with “Sieg Heil”, and heil, indeed, proceeded to break loose.
In addition to the Vaillancourt affair, there was the Bob Mead controversy. Mead is a former Republican legislator who served as O’Brien’s chief of staff. O’Brien shunted Mead aside in favor of Republican operative Greg Moore following the eruption of several controversies during the 2011 session. As a consolation prize, Mead was given a job in the House majority leader’s office. In the last couple of weeks, news broke that Mead, whose job was “legislative outreach,” had taken mileage reimbursement for attending meetings around the state where he was recruiting Republican legislative candidates. Even in Bill O’Brien’s New Hampshire, the use of taxpayer dollars for partisan political purposes is not acceptable — if made public. Mead left his post, leaving several unanswered questions. Why did Greg Moore, who signed the reimbursement authorizations, also not resign? Did Speaker O’Brien and the House majority leader, DJ Bettencourt, in whose office Mead was working, know that Mead thought an appropriate purpose of his taxpayer-funded job was doing the work of the New Hampshire Republican Party? If they did know, and they authorized Mead’s activities, shouldn’t they be resigning as well?
The Vaillancourt blow-up, and to a lesser extent, the Mead mini-scandal, overshadowed a more serious controversy: the war that has erupted against New Hampshire’s public schools. It is not just about the Claremont decision and the allocation of state resources to public schools anymore. There are legislators whose sneering references to “government schools” makes one wonder if they are still resentful over being put in the corner for their bad behavior in second grade. Then there are local government officials like Manchester Mayor Ted Gatsas, who look at the education of children as an onerous burden, not the most important of responsibilities.
Legislative leadership is attempting feverishly to cobble together a constitutional amendment that will gain enough support to be put on the November ballot. The initial efforts were envisioned as a way to permit the state to target aid to communities that need help more than others, while eliminating future lawsuits. But for many in the New Hampshire House, the goal apparently is to eliminate the state’s responsibility to provide any financial support to the state’s public schools.
The resulting proposal has therefore turned into a bit of a mishmash. On the one hand, it says the Legislature has the responsibility to maintain a system of public education. On the other, it says the Legislature has the authority to decide how much state funding to provide to public schools. This does not make sense. Either the state has the responsibility to maintain public schools, and pay for them, or, the state has no responsibility and does not pay for them. This amendment tries to have it both ways.
I could get behind an amendment that permits the targeting of some school aid to give all New Hampshire’s students a good education no matter where they live, but this amendment does not do that. In addition, it is an invitation to litigation, with language about the Legislature making “wholesome” standards for education. I hope the Legislature votes this one down.
One of the bright spots in the education wars was the successful effort by the students and parents of Bedford High School to save the International Baccalaureate Program from the slightly whacky legislators who confused academic rigor with an international conspiracy. It was heartening to see a community come together to fight fiction with facts for the betterment of the children.
As a lifelong resident of Manchester, I hate to say it, but Bedford is putting the Queen City to shame. Here, Mayor Ted Gatsas can find $250,000 for golf course drainage, but chairs a school board and oversees an aldermanic board who may eliminate Latin, German, some music and other courses, in addition to the successful dropout prevention PASS Program.
Eliminate Latin? Does this mean Gatsas will change the name of Central High’s Classical Building to the “Whatever” Building? And German? Perhaps the mayor has not noticed, but we live in a global economy and Germany is one of the countries at the forefront.
If elected officials don’t understand the correlation between strong public schools and our future prosperity and security, then they are in need of some remedial education themselves. Hopefully, the voters will provide one.
Kathy Sullivan is a Manchester attorney and a member of the Democratic National Committee. She was chairman of the New Hampshire Democratic Party from 1999-2007.
In addition to the Vaillancourt affair, there was the Bob Mead controversy. Mead is a former Republican legislator who served as O’Brien’s chief of staff. O’Brien shunted Mead aside in favor of Republican operative Greg Moore following the eruption of several controversies during the 2011 session. As a consolation prize, Mead was given a job in the House majority leader’s office. In the last couple of weeks, news broke that Mead, whose job was “legislative outreach,” had taken mileage reimbursement for attending meetings around the state where he was recruiting Republican legislative candidates. Even in Bill O’Brien’s New Hampshire, the use of taxpayer dollars for partisan political purposes is not acceptable — if made public. Mead left his post, leaving several unanswered questions. Why did Greg Moore, who signed the reimbursement authorizations, also not resign? Did Speaker O’Brien and the House majority leader, DJ Bettencourt, in whose office Mead was working, know that Mead thought an appropriate purpose of his taxpayer-funded job was doing the work of the New Hampshire Republican Party? If they did know, and they authorized Mead’s activities, shouldn’t they be resigning as well?
The Vaillancourt blow-up, and to a lesser extent, the Mead mini-scandal, overshadowed a more serious controversy: the war that has erupted against New Hampshire’s public schools. It is not just about the Claremont decision and the allocation of state resources to public schools anymore. There are legislators whose sneering references to “government schools” makes one wonder if they are still resentful over being put in the corner for their bad behavior in second grade. Then there are local government officials like Manchester Mayor Ted Gatsas, who look at the education of children as an onerous burden, not the most important of responsibilities.
Legislative leadership is attempting feverishly to cobble together a constitutional amendment that will gain enough support to be put on the November ballot. The initial efforts were envisioned as a way to permit the state to target aid to communities that need help more than others, while eliminating future lawsuits. But for many in the New Hampshire House, the goal apparently is to eliminate the state’s responsibility to provide any financial support to the state’s public schools.
The resulting proposal has therefore turned into a bit of a mishmash. On the one hand, it says the Legislature has the responsibility to maintain a system of public education. On the other, it says the Legislature has the authority to decide how much state funding to provide to public schools. This does not make sense. Either the state has the responsibility to maintain public schools, and pay for them, or, the state has no responsibility and does not pay for them. This amendment tries to have it both ways.
I could get behind an amendment that permits the targeting of some school aid to give all New Hampshire’s students a good education no matter where they live, but this amendment does not do that. In addition, it is an invitation to litigation, with language about the Legislature making “wholesome” standards for education. I hope the Legislature votes this one down.
One of the bright spots in the education wars was the successful effort by the students and parents of Bedford High School to save the International Baccalaureate Program from the slightly whacky legislators who confused academic rigor with an international conspiracy. It was heartening to see a community come together to fight fiction with facts for the betterment of the children.
As a lifelong resident of Manchester, I hate to say it, but Bedford is putting the Queen City to shame. Here, Mayor Ted Gatsas can find $250,000 for golf course drainage, but chairs a school board and oversees an aldermanic board who may eliminate Latin, German, some music and other courses, in addition to the successful dropout prevention PASS Program.
Eliminate Latin? Does this mean Gatsas will change the name of Central High’s Classical Building to the “Whatever” Building? And German? Perhaps the mayor has not noticed, but we live in a global economy and Germany is one of the countries at the forefront.
If elected officials don’t understand the correlation between strong public schools and our future prosperity and security, then they are in need of some remedial education themselves. Hopefully, the voters will provide one.
Kathy Sullivan is a Manchester attorney and a member of the Democratic National Committee. She was chairman of the New Hampshire Democratic Party from 1999-2007.
- Jury overrules panel, awards malpractice verdict in son's death - 21
- Judge continues case against Keene parking meter 'Robin Hoods' - 35
- Teen told no fish story: He's the official derby winner - 0
- Pembroke man's family stunned by his shooting by Manchester police - 0
- New Conway library director coming from Manchester - 0
- Updated: Old Epping cemetery disturbed - 0
- Naturalization ceremony welcomes 26 new Americans - 1
- Pinkerton students pause to remember Lt. Paul DeMeo - 1
- Merrimack student’s death called suicide - 0
Exeter teachers were kids' favorites
READER COMMENTS: 6- Londonderry students who haven't had whooping cough vaccine asked to stay home - 0
- House, Senate agree on capital budget, including new $38 million women's prison - 0
- Windham's Common Man suffers heavy water damage in fire - 0
- Elderly man critical after North Hampton camper fire - 0
- 'Home grow' dropped on way to medical marijuana compromise - 7
- Death investigation under way in Manchester, no foul play suspected - 0
- Vet Home budget reworked after proposed cuts - 0
- Enfield fire leaves one burned - 0
- Driver rescued after Franklin crash, 50-foot plunge - 0
Hooksett students taken to nearby school after gas leak
READER COMMENTS: 0
Sorry, no question available



